No More Mr. Nice Guy

Dateline: 12/03/97
Team Pages
NBA.com
ESPNet
CNN/SI
Golden St. Woe-riors
Statistics
J. of Basketball Studies
CNN/SI
NBA.com
ESPNet
Related Content
Power of Parity
Records
Predicted: 28-54
1996-97: 30-52
Stat Selector
Off. Rtg.
Def. Rtg.

Sc. Poss.
Poss.
Floor%
Pts. Prod.
NBA Preview Pages

Click Here for Main Page
Team Statistics

"NO MORE MR. NICE GUY" is the Warriors' slogan this year. Their billboards feature the coaching staff wearing suits and sunglasses. If they were truly trying to live up to that slogan, though, they'd start wearing shorts below the knees...

...Then again, they should get extra credit points for Latrell Sprewell.

Sprewell's assault of coach P.J. Carlesimo was just the latest in a mostly nonverbal war on the Golden State authority. On arrival in camp this fall, Sprewell didn't mesh with the new coaching staff and decided not to speak to the media. He missed practice, missed flights, and apparently missed the lecture on how to be a team player.

The Warriors, for their part, have been trying to trade Spree since day 1, desperately seeking something more than Sean Elliott for their former All-Star. Sprewell knew about this potential trade and approached San Antonio coach/GM, Greg Popovich, during a Warriors-Spurs game and said, "Come on, trade for me. Pull the trigger." Finally, tonight, the Warriors pulled the trigger and fired Sprewell, terminating his contract, an unprecedented move.

Ostensibly, the move was to rid the team of an insubordinate player. But the move also helps the salary cap situation, which was very bad for the Warriors who were paying $8 million to their Employee of the Month. No trade other than one bringing bad players in could have helped with the salary cap. It was a convenient termination. Local fans cheered it.

...Not The Same For You And Me...

Oddly, people are comparing Sprewell's actions to those of a regular worker: "If I choked my boss at work, I'd get fired on the spot. I'd get arrested."

Pro athletics are nothing like real work, though. Nothing like it.

Your boss doesn't yell at you during the day, but Pat Riley gets praised for it. It's not professional for a boss to berate an employee unless that boss is a coach.

We perhaps foolishly pay to see things in pro sports that we would never see in our boring workplace. Obnoxious coaching is part of that. The violent response from Latrell Sprewell is another part of it.

It is hard to condone violence in any form and Sprewell's form was over the line (whatever it was -- since the details have yet to be fully reported). But to say it was unprofessional, not appropriate for a worker -- the comparison is wrong because the work environment of a pro athlete is so different. It ain't Dilbert's World, that's for sure.

...So What's The Bum Worth?...

Back to business. Business in basketball is evaluating players. Sprewell's value is -- even ignoring the attitude -- not that great.

Sprewell has complimentary talents. He has even said it himself. Taking the lead on the Warriors team made him look bad.

I created a ranking of the most overrated players, simply comparing a player's offensive rating to his defensive rating if he uses more than 15 possessions per game. Below is the list as of 12/1/97:

Most Overrated Players

Rank Name Team Off.
Rtg.
Def.
Rtg.
1 Rodney Rogers LAC 97.5 113.9
2 Latrell Sprewell gsw 96.8 110.4
3 Donyell Marshall gsw 96.6 106.9
4 Eric Williams den 99.9 108.7
5 Juwan Howard Was 96.7 105.4
6 Shareef Abdur-Rahim Van 99.9 106.5
7 Jerry Stackhouse Phi 100.5 106.4
8 Damon Stoudamire Tor 105.6 111.1
9 Antoine Walker bos 94.3 99.4
10 David Wesley cha 101.6 106.6
11 Michael Finley dal 103.6 108.2
12 Grant Hill det 92.9 96.4
13 Anfernee Hardaway Orl 100.7 104.2
14 John Wallace Tor 105.2 108.6
15 Rod Strickland Was 101.6 104.5
16 Stephon Marbury Min 103.3 105.9
17 Kobe Bryant LAL 98.6 100.4
18 Jason Kidd Pho 102.4 101.7
19 Isaiah Rider Por 103.6 102.5
20 Brent Barry LAC 114.1 112.9
21 Lindsey Hunter det 99.8 98.3
22 Brian Williams det 100.1 98.0
23 Mitch Richmond Sac 110.0 107.7
24 Glenn Robinson Mil 105.1 102.8
25 Kendall Gill NJN 99.6 97.2
Players taking more than 15 possessions per game with the worst difference between offensive and defensive ratings. Raw stats courtesy of The Master of Da Stats, err, Doug Steele.

Obviously, there are some pretty good players on this list. Penny Hardaway and Grant Hill are destined to be Hall of Famers, but haven't been playing too well this year.

Sprewell's presence at #2 doesn't mean he's awful. It just indicates that any team built around him is not going to be all that great. He was a fine player when he played with Chris Mullin, Chris Webber, and Tim Hardaway. I'm sure he would have made the list of underrated players if I'd had such a thing. But being a showpiece player was something he could not do.

He'll get a second chance in the league because teams know this.

...And because pro sports are not real life.